Interview:
Is Google's new "Pay-Per-Action" program worth
the hype?
By
Derek Gehl & Nicole Ephgrave
[Ed note: Nicole Ephgrave is our in-house SEO "wizard."
You can meet up with her in our exclusive "members-only"
Search Marketing Lab. To learn more about the lab, click
here:
marketingtips.com/searchmarketinglab]
I recently sat down with search marketing expert Nicole
Ephgrave to talk about Google's much-hyped new "Pay-Per-Action"
program. Here's what she had to say:
Derek: What's the deal with Google's
new pay-per-action program?
Nicole: Instead of the regular pay-per-click
model -- where advertisers pay every time someone clicks
on their ad -- Google's new pay-per-action program allows
advertisers to pay only when people who click on their
ad take a certain
action.
Derek: What kind of "action"?
Nicole: A purchase, newsletter subscription,
new lead acquisition -- it's up to you as the advertiser. You define
the action and how much you're willing to pay for people
to take that action. Then you set up your conversion
tracking and create an ad for potential publishers to
put on their sites.
Derek: Who are these potential publishers?
Where would your ads get displayed?
Nicole: On Google's content network--online
newspapers, information sites, AdSense publishers and
so on.
Derek: Everywhere you'd see regular
AdSense ads show up, in other words. So who can sign
up for it? Is it available for small business owners
or only for big spenders?
Nicole: Oh no, it's intended for use
by everybody. Right now it's still in beta, though --
and all the spots are currently full. But more spots
will open up over the next couple of months. It's only
available to U.S. advertisers at the moment, but it'll
go global sometime in the next few months, I'm sure.
Derek: How do you get a spot on the
waiting list?
Nicole: You sign up at:
http://services.google.com/payperaction/.
You have to be an AdWords advertiser to be eligible,
though.
Derek: How does the cost compare to
Google's regular pay-per-click program?
Nicole:
That's up to you as the advertiser. Maybe you're willing
to spend $2 for every newsletter subscriber you get --
or $4 for every sale. No matter how many people click
on the ad and go to your site, you don't pay a penny
until someone takes the action you specified. Cool,
don't you think?
Derek: Very. But what about the publishers?
Is it a good deal for them?
Nicole: I think the jury's still out
on that. It certainly could be, provided the ad was
targeted to their visitors.
Derek: Do they get to choose the ads
that get displayed on their sites?
Nicole: Yes, definitely. Smart publishers
are going to look for well-targeted ads that hold strong
appeal for their site visitors. Those are the ads that'll
make them the most money.
Derek: That's obviously something you
need to be aware of, as an advertiser.
Nicole: Yes. You have to have a well-written
ad that actually encourages people to click on it --
and the website it leads to has to do a good job of
converting visitors into buyers.
And you can't put too
low a bid on your ads. If they don't make publishers good
money, no one's going to want to publish them.
Derek: Your ad copy plays an important
role.
Nicole: For sure. Your ad has to catch
people's attention and present an appealing offer --
otherwise no one's going to click on it.
Your ad also has
to give people an accurate idea of what they'll find
when they land on your site -- otherwise they'll leave,
annoyed you wasted their time. Your publishers aren't
going to want
that to happen!
Derek: So how do potential publishers
find your ad?
Nicole: Through their AdSense accounts.
They use keywords or browse through categories to find
ads that are a good match for their site.
Derek: Pay-per-action comes with a
much higher price tag than regular pay-per-click advertising.
Do you think the extra money is worth it?
Nicole: It sure could be. After all,
most of the risk is with the publisher. You just have
to do the math and make sure you don't end up paying
too much for your specified action.
Derek: Some say pay-per-action is the
cure for click fraud. What do you think?
Nicole: Well, if it takes off, it'll
certainly take a huge bite out of it. That could be
great for the whole industry. But will it lead to another
type of merchant fraud? We'll have to wait and see.
Derek: What kind of feedback have you
been hearing about the program so far?
Nicole: To be honest, there hasn't
been much feedback yet. It was released just a few months
ago.
But I do have a word of caution for publishers:
watch your ROI. You have to make sure you're getting
more money with the pay-per-action ads than you would
with regular AdSense ads. Otherwise, why make the switch?